The ACA Times


  Show menu
  • Home
  • Articles
  • Get to Know the ACA
  • ACA – Frequently Asked Questions
  • Resources
  • Meet the Editors
  • Trusaic
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Notice
  
  • Home
  • Premium Tax Credit
  • Excess PTCs Can Lead To Greater Tax Liability

Articles

Excess PTCs Can Lead To Greater Tax Liability

September 14, 2017 Robert Sheen Premium Tax Credit
Excess PTCs Can Lead To Greater Tax Liability

The Affordable Care Act (ACA) has made significant strides in making healthcare affordable thanks to subsidies like Premium Tax Credits (PTCs), but that assistance can ultimately affect tax liability. At the close of August, the U.S. Tax Court issued a ruling that, under tax code Sec. 36B, individuals who received an excess of advanced PTCs were required to report that increase to be repaid as a tax.

The case referenced by the court was McGuire v. Commissioner. The McGuires, a married couple, received an advance PTC in 2014. Sometime during the tax year, the wife began working. Her earnings shifted the couple’s earnings above their applicable cutoff based on federal poverty line, making them ineligible for the PTC they had already received. The excess was not reported by the couple on their tax return.

Under Sec. 36B, “The term ‘premium assistance credit amount’ means, with respect to any taxable year, the sum of the premium assistance amounts…with respect to all coverage months of the taxpayer occurring during the taxable year.”

When an individual receives an advance PTC, that payment goes to health insurance providers to contribute towards the premiums for plans purchased on the Health Insurance Marketplace. Financial change will alter a taxpayer’s eligibility to that credit. Take the married McGuires, where one spouse’s returning to work added more to the total family income, bringing them above applicable cutoff based on the Federal Poverty Line. That increase should be reflected on an annual tax return, where the excess PTCs would need to be repaid. However, in the case of McGuire v. Commissioner it was not. In this instance, the Tax Court noted:

The McGuires did not have notice that they were being charged with taxable income. Like the taxpayers in Frias and Nipps, the McGuires relied on a third party to fulfill its obligations; they reported their change in financial circumstances to Covered California and relied on Covered California to properly determine and adjust their eligibility for the premium assistance tax credit. For whatever reason, that did not happen.

A taxpayer’s reliance on the advice of a qualified tax professional can also contribute to a reasonable cause and good-faith defense to a substantial understatement penalty. Sec. 1.6664-4(b)(1), Income Tax Regs. While the record is sparse, we note that the McGuires relied on a certified public accountant to properly prepare their tax return.

The result of this case is less of a punishment and more of a cautionary tale. Taxpayers need to be mindful of changes in income that may make the ineligible for PTCs. If they do become ineligible but still receive PTCs, such excess PTCs must be repaid.

Additionally, reliance on a CPA may provide some cover. That said, taxpayers should be sure to inform the CPA of any significant changes in income that might impact eligibility for a PTC. This should cause the CPA to investigate the situation, particularly in light of this tax case.

We’re committed to helping companies reduce risk, avoid penalties, and achieve 100% ACA compliance. For questions about the ACA contact us here.

Summary
Excess PTCs Can Lead To Greater Tax Liability
Article Name
Excess PTCs Can Lead To Greater Tax Liability
Description
News from the U.S. Tax Court at the close of August shows how those individuals who received an excess in Premium Tax Credits may find themselves with an increase in their tax liability. Read on to see how some taxpayers failed to report that increase and why CPAs should keep this case in mind.
Author
Robert Sheen
Publisher Name
The ACA Times
Publisher Logo
The ACA Times
Short URL of this page: https://acatimes.com/lto
Robert Sheen

Robert Sheen

Esq., is Editor-in-Chief of The ACA Times. He also is founder, president and CEO of Trusaic.

Robert Sheen is Founder and President of Trusaic. Robert is a graduate of the University of Southern California, in Business Administration with an emphasis in International Finance. He earned his Juris Doctor from Loyola Law School, Los Angeles, concentrating in Tax Law.

View more by Robert Sheen

Related tags to article

Affordable Care ActCovered CaliforniaFederal Poverty LineHealth Insurance MarketplaceHealthcareMcGuire v. CommissionerPremium Tax CreditU.S. Tax Court
Related Articles New York Pay Transparency Law Delayed to November New York Pay Transparency Law Delayed to November
Related Articles Takeaways From the 2021 UK Gender Pay Gap Reporting Results Takeaways From the 2021 UK Gender Pay Gap Reporting Results
Related Articles LinkedIn Settlement Demonstrates Need For Accurate Pay Equity Audits LinkedIn Settlement Demonstrates Need For Accurate Pay Equity Audits
Related Articles Administration Predicts Lower ACA Enrollment by Robert Sheen  •  
Related Articles IRS Eases Rules on Hardship Exemptions by Robert Sheen  •  
Related Articles HHS Awards $36 Million To Health Centers by Robert Sheen  •  
ACA Essential Guide for Employers 2021
Subscribe

Popular Posts

  • IRS Proposed Ruling Could Change ACA Affordability
  • ACA Penalty Letter 226J on The Rise
  • New PTC Data is Cause For Concern For Employers
  • ACA Enrollment Reaches 35 Million Signups

Trending Topics

  • Regulations
    (91)
  • Legislation
    (47)
  • Editorials
    (19)
  • ACA Compliance
    (167)
  • Tax Filings
    (19)
  • Applicable Large Employer (ALE)
    (13)
  • Penalties
    (18)
  • IRS
    (87)
  • Health Insurance Marketplace
    (28)
  • Polls/Surveys
    (18)
  • Health Care Reform
    (22)
  • Reporting
    (22)
  • IRS 226J/226-J
    (28)

Categories


Brought to you by Trusaic

 

Twitter Facebook

Downloads

The ACA 101 Toolkit

The Essential Guide to the ACA

Letter 226J Infographic

5 Common ACA Compliance Mistakes

Triangle of Trust

Articles

IRS Affordability Safe Harbors Help Avoid ACA Penalties

Calculating FT and FTE Employees

The ACA Monthly Measurement Method: A Few Examples

The IRS’s 1095 Forms for ACA Explained

Incorrect ITINs Will Cause Havoc With ACA Compliance

Knowledge Center

Get to know the ACA

Get to know Letter 226J

Webinar: What triggers an ACA penalty

Trusaic News

Our Story


FEATURED IN

Human Resources Today
Connected Health Pulse

© 2021 Copyright Trusaic - All Rights reserved.

Close Window

Loading, Please Wait!

This may take a second or two. Loading, Please Wait!