The ACA Times


  Show menu
  • Home
  • Articles
  • Get to Know the ACA
  • ACA – Frequently Asked Questions
  • Resources
  • Meet the Editors
  • Trusaic
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Notice
  
  • Home
  • Affordable Care Act
  • House Can Sue Administration on ACA Funding

Articles

House Can Sue Administration on ACA Funding

September 21, 2015 Robert Sheen Affordable Care Act, Legislation, Regulations
House Can Sue Administration on ACA Funding

The House of Representatives can pursue its lawsuit against the Obama gavel_300Administration that claims funding of subsidies under the Affordable Care Act violate the Constitution.

Judge Rosemary M. Collyer of the U.S. District Court in Washington, D.C., noted that her decision only cleared the way for the House to pursue its lawsuit, and “the merits of this lawsuit await another day.” The Administration said it will appeal the ruling.

Led primarily by its Republican members, the House of Representatives filed the lawsuit in November of 2014 against Sylvia Burwell, the Secretary of Health and Human Services (HHS) and Jacob Lew, Secretary of the Treasury.

The suit argues that by issuing the subsidies, the Secretaries “spent billions of unappropriated dollars” to support the ACA, in violation of the Constitution’s requirement that all federal spending must be appropriated by Congress.

The Administration argued that the House lacked standing to sue and stop the expenditure for which Congress had not appropriated funds. Attorneys for the House responded that it did have to stand because, as a result of the Secretaries’ actions, it had been “divested utterly and completely of its most defining constitutional function.”

On this issue, wrote the judge, “the Court agrees: the constitutional trespass alleged in this case would inflict a concrete, particular harm upon the House for which it has the standing to seek redress in this Court.”

The Constitution “vests Congress with exclusive power over the federal purse,” the judge wrote. “Yet this constitutional structure would collapse, and the role of the House would be meaningless if the Executive could circumvent the appropriations process and spend funds however it pleases.”

The court rejected a second claim in the House’s lawsuit, that the Administration’s decision to change enforcement of the Employer’s Mandate also subverted the role of the House. That’s an argument over the implementation of a statute, not a constitutional question, the judge ruled, and on that issue, the House does not have the standing to sue.

We’re committed to helping companies reduce risk, avoid penalties, and achieve 100% ACA compliance. For questions about the ACA contact us here.

Short URL of this page: https://acatimes.com/cea
Robert Sheen

Robert Sheen

Esq., is editor-in-chief of The ACA Times. He also is founder, president and CEO of Trusaic.

Robert Sheen is Founder and President of Trusaic. Robert is a graduate of the University of Southern California, in Business Administration with an emphasis in International Finance. He earned his Juris Doctor from Loyola Law School, Los Angeles, concentrating in Tax Law.

View more by Robert Sheen
Related Articles EEOC Gears up for the Return of EEO-1 Component 2 Pay Data Reporting EEOC Gears up for the Return of EEO-1 Component 2 Pay Data Reporting
Related Articles Roe v. Wade Decision Signals Loss of Equality Roe v. Wade Decision Signals Loss of Equality
Related Articles California SB 1162 Continues Through State Legislature California SB 1162 Continues Through State Legislature
ACA Essential Guide for Employers 2021
Subscribe

Popular Posts

  • Get to Know the ACA’s Rule of Parity
  • What Employers Need to Know About the California Individual Mandate
  • What you Need to Know About IRS Letter 5699
  • Handling Seasonal Employees and Workers is Critical for ACA Compliance
  • The 2022 ACA 101 Toolkit is Here
  • These Industries are Most at Risk for ACA Penalties From the IRS

Trending Topics

  • Regulations
    (91)
  • Legislation
    (47)
  • Editorials
    (19)
  • ACA Compliance
    (169)
  • Tax Filings
    (19)
  • Applicable Large Employer (ALE)
    (13)
  • Penalties
    (19)
  • IRS
    (86)
  • Health Insurance Marketplace
    (28)
  • Polls/Surveys
    (18)
  • Health Care Reform
    (22)
  • Reporting
    (22)
  • IRS 226J/226-J
    (28)

Categories


Brought to you by Trusaic

 

Twitter Facebook

Downloads

The ACA 101 Toolkit

The Essential Guide to the ACA

Letter 226J Infographic

5 Common ACA Compliance Mistakes

Triangle of Trust

Articles

IRS Affordability Safe Harbors Help Avoid ACA Penalties

Calculating FT and FTE Employees

The ACA Monthly Measurement Method: A Few Examples

The IRS’s 1095 Forms for ACA Explained

Incorrect ITINs Will Cause Havoc With ACA Compliance

Knowledge Center

Get to know the ACA

Get to know Letter 226J

Webinar: What triggers an ACA penalty

Trusaic News

Our Story


FEATURED IN

Human Resources Today
Connected Health Pulse

© 2021 Copyright Trusaic - All Rights reserved.

Close Window

Loading, Please Wait!

This may take a second or two. Loading, Please Wait!